An appraiser would often consider four types of discounts when valuing holding businesses: a discount for loss of control, a liquidation discount, a discount for lack of marketability, & a discount for co-tenancy (which is also called a discount for an undivided interest in the real estate).
What precisely are valuation discounts?
A valuation discount is a difference in value that a buyer perceives between a company's peers in the same industry. Buyers would commonly review comparable transactions as part of their due diligence before finalizing a purchase. This study includes a collection of multiples that are regularly utilized in most transactions. If the buyer is willing to pay less than or equal to the low end of this range, the target company has unfavorable characteristics that warrant a valuation discount.
In the business valuation process, how do valuation discounts work?
Transactions between buyers and sellers determine the fair market value of a company's investment. The ultimate calculation of fair market value requires the company valuator to identify and consider those ownership interest characteristics that are distinctive to the interest being valued under commonly accepted valuation procedures and methodologies.
Investors are hesitant to take risks. Ownership interest characteristics that increase the risk of holding the investment decrease the value of the ownership interest. Those characteristics that reduce investment risk will also increase the value of that ownership stake. The appropriateness of any discount cannot be determined until the basis for the adjustments is defined.
Discounts and premiums cannot produce the desired result if applied to an incorrect base value conclusion. There are no "predefined" discounts or premium ranges from which the evaluator can find the appropriate changes for a given situation.
Metrics involved in business valuation that affect valuation discounts
The following are some of the metrics that influence business valuation discounts:
- Purpose of the valuation - Is our valuation for divorce, estate, ESOP, or other purposes?
- Valuation of ancillary rights and attribute of a specific ownership stake
- The voting vs. non-voting share structure of the company is under consideration.
- Management team quality - inexperienced management, low-income family ties
- Company size - The valuation discounts are determined by the size of the company, whether it is a small business or a large multifunctional enterprise.
- Taking into account the size of the stock block which is being valued - a swing vote
- Appropriateness of managerial wages, benefits, and perquisites - excessive pay and/or benefits
- Concerns about stock include dividend policy, stock redemption policies, and stock-related restrictions- the first right of refusal, sales, and so on.
- Federal and state regulatory constraints include Treasury controls on estates, Department of Labor laws on employee stock ownership plans, and state corporation statutes requiring a supermajority in New York/Illinois.
Valuation discounts
When a company is valued, its ability to generate future cash flows is generally assessed, with the present value of those cash flows estimating its worth to investors. In practice, however, such exercises do not provide a real representation of the worth of the company on its own.
There are contextual and situational aspects of a transaction that must be accounted for that are not accounted for in the financial statements.
Valuation discount types
Inadequate marketability, lack of control, a minority stake, and future interest discounts. Depending on various factors, these savings can range from 11% to 45%.
- Discount by lack of control
A discount by lack of control is a reduction in the value of a company's stock caused by a shareholder's inability to exercise control over the company. Because corporate decisions such as establishing remuneration, defining policy, deciding to sell or liquidate, & declaring dividends are all out of the hands of shareholders, this is almost always considered worth less than a controlling interest in a company.
As a result, when non-controlling or non-voting shares of a private corporation are valued, a discount for lack of control is frequently imposed.
- Discount for lack of marketability
Discounts for lack of marketability are a method for determining the value of closely held and restricted shares (DLOM). The underlying assumption of DLOM is that there is a valuation of discount between a publicly traded stock with a market and a privately held stock with little or no market.
To quantify the discount that may be applied, the IPO method, the limited stock approach, and the option pricing methods have all been used. The difference between a company's common stock and its restricted stock, according to the restricted stock technique, is its lack of marketability.
- Discount for liquidation
As we know, liquidation is the process of closing the business and distributing its assets to claimants in finance and economics. The term "liquidation" may also refer to the sale of non-performing goods at any price which is lower than the cost to the company or the price desired by the company. It is common for a company to be insolvent, which means that it is unable to meet its obligations when they are due.
When a company's operations end, the remaining assets are generally used to pay creditors and shareholders in descending order. For general partners, a liquidation is an option.
Co-tenancy discount
A co-tenancy discount is offered when the appraised equity interest owns the undivided interest in real estate. The authors will not go into detail in this paper since there are so many factors to consider while analyzing this discount. Instead, the authors aim to make clear that this discount is founded on research that is comparable to that done for the other discounts previously covered, with the difference that it only applies to an undivided interest in real estate.
Application of valuation discounts
Discounts may be given to the projected value of the operational business to reflect a lack of liquidity and ownership rights or restrictions, depending on the type of interest, degree of value, and assumptions used in developing cash flows.
- The Net Asset Value was discounted for Tenancy prior to Cotenancy Discount.
- Net Asset Value (NAV): (-) Liquidation Discount (either the actual cost amount or percent of Net Asset Value)
- The value of a Marketable, 100% Controlling Interest (-) Price reduction due to the lack of control (the percent of the Controlling, Marketable Interest Value)
- A 100 percent non-controlling, marketable interest is extremely valuable.
- If any of the preceding discounts do not apply to the assessed equity, they can be discarded; however, the order of the remaining discounts should be maintained.
Holding corporations are eligible for a variety of discounts. The appraiser must have a complete understanding of the organization, its purpose and operational structure, as well as the equity rights granted to its interest holders, in order to apply the proper discounts and produce a reasonable estimate of value for a corporation.
Conclusion
Business owners are aware of the facts and circumstances surrounding their business. They carefully examine what they are purchasing before making an offer. They, like most people, prefer to be in charge, and they prefer investments that can be easily converted into cash if necessary.
Arrowfish Consulting is the place to go if you are a busy attorney looking for a damages expert to meet a tight deadline, any business owner in Dallas looking for an appraiser, or a manufacturing company in Denver looking for a dependable business interruption loss analysis. We'll give you the best professional service possible at prices that are reasonable and cater to your individual needs.
