logo
logo
Products 

Common Coding Errors Auditors Find in E/M Visits

avatar
Mike Dave
Authority
collect
0
collect
0
collect
6
Common Coding Errors Auditors Find in E/M Visits

Evaluation and management visits, often called E/M visits, are the most common services billed by most medical practices. Office visits, follow-ups, hospital rounds, and telehealth check-ins all fall into this group. Because they are billed so often, even small mistakes in E/M coding can add up to large amounts of money over a year.

E/M coding is also one of the areas payers watch most closely. Auditors know that level selection is not always easy, and that rules have changed several times in recent years. When they review a practice, E/M visits are usually the first place they look.

The good news is that most E/M errors follow clear patterns. Once you know what auditors look for, you can find and fix these problems before a payer does. Many practices use Medical Billing And Coding Audit Services to review their E/M claims on a regular basis and catch issues early.

In this article, we will walk through the most common E/M coding errors auditors find, why they happen, and simple steps your practice can take to avoid them.

Why E/M Visits Get So Much Attention

E/M codes make up a large share of claims for primary care, internal medicine, pediatrics, and many specialties. Payers compare each provider’s coding pattern with others in the same specialty. If a provider bills far more level 4 or level 5 visits than their peers, it can trigger a review.

Since 2021 for office visits, and 2023 for most other settings, E/M levels are chosen based on medical decision making (MDM) or total time on the date of the encounter. Many providers are still adjusting to these rules, which leads to honest mistakes in both directions.

1. Choosing a Level the Notes Do Not Support

This is the most common error auditors find. The provider selects a level 4 or 5 visit, but the documentation only supports a lower level. In other cases, the provider picks a lower level than the notes support, which is called undercoding.

Common causes include:

  • Not understanding how MDM is scored
  • Counting problems or data that are not clearly documented
  • Relying on habit instead of the details of each visit
  • Letting the EHR suggest a level without review

Overcoding can lead to payer recoupments. Undercoding quietly costs the practice money it has earned.

2. Time-Based Coding Without Proper Documentation

When a provider bills based on time, the note must show the total time spent on the date of service. Auditors often find notes that say “spent extra time with patient” but list no minutes. Others include time for activities that do not count, such as separately billed services or travel.

To bill by time correctly, the note should include:

  • The total minutes spent on the date of the encounter
  • A short list of what the time included, such as reviewing records, counseling, or ordering tests
  • A clear statement that the level was chosen based on time

3. Misuse of Modifier 25

Modifier 25 is used when a provider performs a significant, separately identifiable E/M service on the same day as a procedure. Auditors often find it added to every visit that includes a minor procedure, even when the E/M work was just part of the procedure itself.

The note should clearly show that the provider addressed a separate problem or did work beyond the usual pre-procedure evaluation. If it does not, the E/M charge may be denied or recouped.

4. New vs Established Patient Errors

A new patient is one who has not received professional services from the same provider, or another provider of the same specialty in the same group, within the past three years. Auditors regularly find established patients billed with new patient codes, especially when a patient sees a different doctor in the same group.

Checking visit history before choosing the code can prevent most of these errors.

5. Copy and Paste Documentation

EHR tools make it easy to copy notes from one visit to the next. But when large parts of a note are the same as the last visit, auditors may question whether the work was actually done. Copied exam findings, outdated problem lists, and repeated plans can weaken support for the billed level.

Providers should update each note to reflect what happened during that specific visit.

6. Missing Signatures and Incomplete Notes

A claim can be correct in every other way and still fail an audit if the note is not signed or is left incomplete. Auditors look for:

  • Provider signatures and credentials
  • Dates that match the date of service
  • Clear identification of who performed the service
  • Complete assessment and plan sections

How to Prevent E/M Coding Errors

Avoiding these errors does not require a major overhaul. A few consistent steps make a real difference:

  • Run internal E/M audits at least once or twice a year for each provider.
  • Compare each provider’s level distribution with national benchmarks.
  • Give providers short, focused training on MDM and time-based coding.
  • Review modifier 25 use on a regular basis.
  • Share audit results with providers and track improvement over time.

An outside audit team can bring a fresh view and help providers understand exactly where their documentation falls short.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should a practice audit its E/M coding?

Most practices benefit from reviewing E/M claims at least once or twice a year for each provider, and more often for new providers.

Is undercoding a compliance problem?

Undercoding is mainly a revenue problem, but consistent coding errors in any direction show that documentation and coding are not lined up.

How many charts are reviewed in a typical E/M audit?

Many audits review a random sample of 10 to 20 visits per provider to spot patterns.

Final Thoughts

E/M visits are the backbone of most medical practices, which is why auditors pay such close attention to them. The most common errors include unsupported levels, weak time documentation, modifier 25 misuse, new versus established patient mix-ups, copied notes, and missing signatures.

By reviewing your own E/M claims before a payer does, you can protect your revenue, lower your audit risk, and give providers the feedback they need to code with confidence.

collect
0
collect
0
collect
6
avatar
Mike Dave
Authority